Relationships: What to do when there's no more "Me and You"
80What do bipolar relationships, grieving, grief and loss, romance, and Maya Angelou have to do with each other? Reading Angelou's ground-breaking and deeply moving, "I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings " proved to be an illuminating experience. Her perceptive explorations gave me the courage to look at my own relationships more deeply, and helped me begin to wring some clarity from the ashes of past, disastrous liaisons. Her words have also given me insight into the troubled relationships among some of my friends, and family members.
I am currently still learning how to live again as a recently-single person, and contemplating the loss of what I thought was true love. I find I have reached an emotional plateau of sorts, from which I can survey the wreckage, and ask some hard questions about what went wrong, and what warning signs I deliberately overlooked.
The plateau on which I now exist emotionally is moderately comfortable, but not a place where I can allow myself to stay for very long. Though it offers a vantage point for reviewing my past and examining that lost relationship, there is no place here for the passions and joys of new love.
I am not speaking of some metaphysical plane of existence, by any means. Rather, I feel a need to withdraw from the "love arena", and spend some time in learning, healing, and gathering strength before I will be ready re-engage fully with life and love.
Now that I am no longer with that person - the one with whom I planned to spend the rest of my life, that is - friends and family are coming forward with expressions of relief at my release from durance vile , as if I had been a prisoner in the relationship.
I must admit I was surprised at first by some of the comments, but time (it's been almost a year ), and distance (I've moved twice since the "breakup" ), is giving me some perspective on the matter. Distance is also giving me a false sense that "things weren't really all that bad." Anyone who has ever been in a dysfunctional or abusive relationship can hear the warning bells already.
You're only fooling yourself...
In any abusive relationship, regardless of the degree of abuse, or whether it is physical, sexual, or emotional abuse, the key element is the control of one person by another.
So, when did we give up control over our life? At what point did this loving, nurturing relationship become a cage? When did someone else's needs become constantly more important than ours? When did their point of view become always more compelling or valid?
I suspect it was the first time we said or thought, "Oh well, it doesn't matter that much, I guess. We can do (whatever I wanted to do ) next time."
Everyone compromises, everyone negotiates, and we are all capable of postponing our own desires in order to honor the needs or wishes of our friends or partner. At some point, though, a line was crossed. We stopped trying to have our needs met.
Maybe we grew tired of always fighting for what we want only to lose out time after time. Maybe we got tired of having our feelings ignored, or being trampled on. Perhaps we began telling ourselves that it was no big deal, or that their way, or idea, or perspective was the right one.
Maybe, as the fight grew more difficult with every repetition, it became unsafe for us to continue insisting on having "our way", on having our wishes honored and our needs met.
Communications became a mine field through which we gingerly picked our way, all the while trying to discern what it was that our partner wanted, so that we could agree to it quickly, without any fuss or unpleasantness.
In a relationship where a bipolar partner refuses to get help, the likelihood of both the partners achieving open and honest communication can be poor to negligible. A close family member is in such a relationship, so I can see first-hand some of the mechanics of their dysfunction.
At first, *Ed (not his real name) seemed to be a great guy. *Lizzy (not her real name) was on the rebound from a disastrous marriage and had recently broken up with a nice but equally messed up live-in friend, so you can imagine we were all thrilled that she had met someone who seemed so bent lavishing her with gifts, affection, and on looking after her every need.
More thoughts on relationships...
- Blue Valentines - Looking For Love
Valentine's Day is all about love and lovers. Symbols of "love" abound - fragrant roses; gourmet chocolates; heart shaped lockets; sexy lingerie; intimate dinners; romantic getaways. All the hype about this day seems aimed at making those among us wh - How Do You Mend a Broken Heart?
GLBT issues; long-term relationships; romance; long-term partner; Come on, ladies. I know in this day and age that women are breaking down the walls of male dominion and excelling in areas formerly thought to be the sole purview of men...but, really, - Signs that Your Marriage is in Trouble
Marriage problems; marriage breakdown; problems relationships; relationship breakdown; danger signs; Sometimes more subtle but nonetheless clear to the trained eye, are the signs that things are not going well. I am somewhat of an expert in this area - Domestic Violence - Are You A Victim?
Domestic violence, spousal abuse, child abuse, elder abuse - we have all heard the words, and seen the stories on the news - the ultimate results of unchecked domestic violence. We abhor the senseless... - Domestic Violence - A Shelter From The Storm
Domestic violence, domestic abuse, spousal abuse - the costs are so high to the victims who may not survive, to the children who may never learn a better way to be and so perpetuate this ill, and to society made sick with this disease...
We had grown used to a certain distance from *Lizzy, as her ex had moved them further and further from family and friends, until she was living in complete isolation. She had also picked up her ex's view point that any expectation of your family that you keep in touch was interference in your life.
After two interventions, she was finally persuaded to move out and start her own life. Unfortunately, like many other caged birds, *Lizzy had forgotten how to fly. She had lost faith in her ability to look after herself. Her confidence had been eroded to the point where she no longer believed that she could manage on her own.
As well, she was in the same boat as many other caged birds - though she had worked all through the marriage, at such low-paying jobs as were available to many women who chose marriage over a career, she now found herself cut loose with no way to survive on her own on the salary she was capable of earning.
*Ed seemed to be the answer to a maiden's prayers - kind, considerate, concerned only with *Lizzy's well-being, and filling her days with fun. He bought her jewelry; he showered her with gifts; he showered her family with gifts.
Then some of *Ed's problems began to surface. *Ed was always right...about everything. Ed's opinion was the only one that mattered...about everything. It became increasingly difficult to have any kind of normal visit, or normal conversation, as every dinner, every holiday gathering soon disintegrated into an *Ed-alogue, in which he held forth at great length.
His stories were repeated verbatim, and in incredible detail, with growing vehemence, though everyone soon learned not to argue, or even mildly disagree. Only movie night was safe - to a point, and only as long as the movie was of *Ed's choosing.
A disturbing obsessiveness began to emerge in his behaviors. He couldn't seem to buy just one of a thing - he had to have every kind of that thing available.
His obsessiveness didn't end there though. It also extended to certain
local politicians. *Ed soon bragged to us that he was on a number of "watch lists", a detail of his life filled us with concern.
Soon we began to hear of, and eventually experience his temper. *Ed had been careful at first to behave towards *Lizzy's family with respect and consideration. As he became more comfortable around us, his true nature began to surface - the erratic temper, the irrational behaviors, the frightening outbursts.
Still, the little bird sang in its cage, afraid to stay, but even more afraid to leave.
So, is it love that binds us together? What exactly is the glue that keeps the relationship limping along, and holds the caged bird in her cage?
There many kinds and degrees of love, and many ways to express it, and though the controllers may avow undying love for the object of their desires, their need to control should not be confused with love. Nor should the gratitude the bird feels, along with the fear and lack of self-esteem that keep the bird in the cage, be confused with feelings of love for her keeper.
These two may in fact feel love for each other, but those feelings are also bound up in the complicated web of fear and control that entangles both their lives...and that leads back to my original questionings about the nature of love.
Is love, in fact, an immutable truth, or merely some transient emotion? Perhaps for some, this is the case. To me, after everything I have experienced and gleaned from the lives of others, love is a decision. It is a decision, or affirmation, if you will, of commitment to another. Making that decision is what causes your face to light up every time they enter the room. Making that decision is what causes you to want to be with that person above all others even after years together. Sometimes, when the going gets a bit rocky, it is a decision that you renew every day.
It can even make you write poetry...
If You Be Love...
If you be love, take then my heart;
In joy, be thou my sun;
Hold fast my hand, and never part;
So share we life as one;
Take thou my days, and in our nights
Our love shall blessèd be;
Where e'er we two with peace abide,
Lives love, eternally.
© 2010, Text by Elle Fredine, All rights reserved.
"If You Be Love", © 2009, Elle Fredine
Latest from RedElf
- A Beginner's Guide to Canoe Polo
This game has been called a cross between water polo, ice hockey, soccer, and basketball. Throw in jousting and daredevil kayaking, and you will have a fair idea of mix - and don't forget kayak... - 2 weeks ago
- Top Best Action Movies for Your Family Movie Nights
Looking for the best action-adventure movies for your family movie night? Spend some fun, quality time at home with a great movie - pass the popcorn! - 2 weeks ago
- Art Easels: How to find the best easel for drawing and painting
What kind of easel is the best one for drawing or painting - for crafting or sketching? Discover the common easel types - styles and best uses. - 2 weeks ago
More Poetry from RedElf
- A Valentine's Gift: Three Love Poems
Ah, St. Valentine's Day. That one day of all the year when we celebrate LOVE. A box of candy wouldn't go amiss, or a pair of sparkling diamond earrings, a diaphanous silk scarf swirling with soft... - 2 years ago
- Where I Again May Love: Heart Springs V
I am presently trying to pick up the pieces of my so-called life and "get on with It", as we are so fond of saying to ourselves. It ain't easy. I find my thoughts flying back to happier... - 2 years ago
- Elegy For A Wedding Band - I took Off Your Love Today
Gardening has always been a passion of mine, and I am finally in lovely little house with a lovely little back garden. It's just the right size - big enough to have lots of room to play, but not so... - 2 years ago
Redelf, this is a lovely hub and I admire that you're so open about your feelings. It was a pleasure to read this, partly because it focussed on the positive side of decisions: time spent after a broken relationship is inevitably spent nursing the wounds that knowing the person you loved and lost at best made small, incremental decisions to leave you.
That you're a great person who can express tenderness so beautifully is one of the reasons I'm your fan.
I am very sorry to hear that and In know how it feels. It takes courage to write about it and I am glad yu did. It doesn;t solve the problem but somehow it helps a little. Wishing you all the very best.
Beautiful Hub and beautiful photos. (I do love birds RE!) Thank you for giving such a clear and educated account of so many aspects of a love relationship. I'm sure you have hit home with many readers who can relate. I relate as a witness to others who have and are going through love life changes and I also relate as a family member who has experienced similar struggles with loved ones other than one's spouse. Sing out loud, it's good being heard.
I love the beautiful poem at the end of this hub. After spending twenty years in an abusive marriage, it was hard for me to trust myself in picking a right relationship. Fortunately for me, I was in therapy for a couple of years before I got the courage to leave, and I continued seeing my therapist afterward. When I finally met someone, over a year later, I had him meet my therapist first, before I would even go out with him. I probably seemed crazy, in hindsight. My point is, I didn't trust myself to fall back into the same patterns of behavior that had entrapped me for so long.
Thanks for this hub. It took courage to be so open.
Namaste.
As I was reading this piece, I saw myself as a caged bird-caged by my own son. The submissiveness is obvious, so as not to enrage him. He is a 22 year old young man who lives close by and visits daily.
Your words sit heavy on my heart. Thank you for opening my eyes.
An abusive relationship that has been endured for any length of time can certainly become a trap. Whether it is fear of retaliation if action to remove one's self is taken or if it is a lack of confidence in one's ability to go it alone--the trap is sprung and gets harder and harder to be freed from with time. I have a friend who I believe is in an emotionally abusive relationship, but refuses to acknowledge it. Anger is the tool for control, and the friend decides what is and what is not worth the price of the anger. Less and less is worth it as time goes on, and it is sad to see.
I feel for everyone trapped in an abusive relationship and hope they find the strength and courage within themselves to do what they must to improve their situation.
Your article was very thought-provoking, and I apologize for my rambling comments in response.
Mike
Beautiful! moving, warm and informative. Keep It 100!
We can't really say what may happen in the future, especially about our relationship. But whatever happens we should always know that our life doesn't end with just one person. Thanks for sharing this very emotional hub.. I just love the truthfulness in your words..
By the way, I love your choice of music.. :D
If you be loved is a beautiful piece. I think we slide into an abusive relationship slowly without our knowledge. By the time we realize it we are in so deep it is hard to find a way out. It is terrible to watch someone we care about going through the "Lizzy" and "Ed" type relationship. Unfortunately all we can do is be there if they need us. My heart goes out to everyone concerned. Beautiful hub.
Hi, thank you for writing such an open and honest piece, and I quite agree how hard it is to escape, I think it can be situations too even if they are not abusive, they can trap you and hold you, for example apart from not wanting to acknowledge it, in my case even though it was not abuse in any way, I found myself and still do totally trapped because of lack of finance and knowhere else to go, so I carry on living in this house with my ex upstairs, I think that after living with someone for such a long time it is always difficult to move even when you know it is the right thing to do, I am so glad that there are people out there that do escape and find happiness somewhere else, thanks nell
Red Elf, I've just finished reading a few relationship Hubs/articles, and I was getting increasingly irritated at how many people seem to think they have all the answers about how to prevent relationship problems and divorce. Then another whole bunch think they know how to have a "happy" divorce and "what both partners need to do". Well, as your Hub points out, it isn't always a matter of "both partners" doing anything. It's a matter of one person knowing s/he has no choice but to leave.
Although my situation was different from yours, what I found (and continue to find) is that "the world" tries to serve you all the answers on a platter - and all anyone offers is a platter full of stuff that doesn't apply to you. As a result, so many of us have to go through that whole sorting process, figuring out what happened, when, and how it happened; and then figuring out what we learned from it.
I read your Hub, here, and thought - "Ah - finally someone who knows the questioning and processing that must go on before we move on." Your Hub comes across as real - and that can be rare in an Internet full of people who don't have a clue what these situations can really be like.
Maybe it's best that we find our own answers, instead of just accepting the easy and canned answers "the world" seems to want us to. What keeps some of us together is the very thing "the world" accuses separated/divorced people of not having - a wish to keep trying, no matter how difficult it is; and a hope that things may get just a little better "one of these days".
On behalf of anyone else who isn't find anyone who "get it" in Hubs or elsewhere on line, thank you for writing this one.
Very well-written and thought out piece. The part about love being a decision is right on. People are difficult at times, love is thorny as hell, so love has to be a decision at times.
After a failed marriage of 14 yrs, I spent 10 more years avoiding anything that required me to trust another person...that too became a cage which kept me from singing as I needed to share life somehow. I took a leap of faith after 10 years and married my best friend. So far, that has been a great decision as friendship seems to pull us through what love cannot. Thanks for a very well-written and enjoyable piece. WB
Love is full of surprises. There are no guarantees that a marriage will stay together, the old saying rings a bell so loud and clear." You really don't know someone until you live a under the same roof with them."
I struggled in my marriages and finally came to the realization that marriage is not for everyone and that one can be HAPPY not been married, yet have tremendous friendships with the opposite sex in so many rewarding ways.
Marriage tends to bring out so many masks in a person who wear them with hurt, pain and malice.
Marriage and loving should almost be a compulsory course in Universities of the world and one must get A+ or else you have to repeat it over again till you get it right and fully comprehend what it really entails.
Thank you for sharing a part of your life with us. I wish you happiness and peace and continual love.
very well done, being in a relationship with a spouse that has amental problem and does not want to deal with it can end a marriage. with counseling and medication there no reason that a person should not get help or a spouse should subject themselves to a life of misery.
ver well done!
Oh Red, I am so sorry. Your poetry comes out in pain like my "gallery" and beauty demands too high a price to want ever to repeat the process. Words alone can't make up the difference but I and your other HP friends will be here every step of your way back to love. I recommend the movie "Must Love Dogs" and "The Holiday" with Jack Black and another Cusak film--"High Fidelity"
Love to you Elle,
Winsome
Having been the caged bird, I applaud your decision: "I feel a need to withdraw from the 'love arena', and spend some time in learning, healing, and gathering strength before I will be ready re-engage fully with life and love."
This is a precious time that you choose to take. When my marriage of 20 years ended, I vowed I would not date for a year (close to the mark where you are). As the year wore on, I found I didn't want to date, translated, I didn't want a relationship. I became comfortable with myself. Several years later, I was ready to consider dating and a relationship.
You are giving yourself a wonderful gift. Your withdrawal is healthy. And your poem is outstanding.
Very well said, I am impressed with how you touched on so many different issues so clearly. I'm an easy going person and found myself married to a control driven person and I, like you said, gave up my control a wee bit at a time untill I woke one day in a miserable place, now divorced and much smarter for it! Plus this reminds me of a song http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t0zDVi7Xxkc&feature It's the theme song to my past marriage, WHEW! Great relationships what to do when there's no more me and you hub!
I can see why you are at 100. Will most definitely come back to this one. Been away awhile - need to learn to juggle better LOL :)


































Paraglider Level 5 Commenter 18 months ago
If you be love - very nice piece to finish. This is well and courageously written. Well done :)